For businesses operating at scale—whether national or international—technical SEO is a cornerstone of success. Optimising large, complex websites requires a strong level of technical expertise that goes beyond surface-level SEO tactics.
The key to choosing the right technical SEO agency lies in understanding the experience and capability of the individuals behind the agency, not just the agency’s brand name or client roster.
1. Focus on the Individual Technical SEO Experts
When vetting a technical SEO agency, the individual expert assigned to your account is crucial. You need to assess their background, experience, and track record. Has the person worked on websites of similar size and complexity to yours? For larger businesses, the right SEO professional must have hands-on experience managing complex technical issues such as:
- Crawling and indexing challenges for large websites.
- Working with enterprise SEO tools
- Site speed and performance improvements.
- International SEO, like handling complex hreflang tags and regional content.
- Identifying problem areas from lists of hundreds of thousands of URL
- Working with client-side dev teams and product managers
It’s essential to look into the individual’s LinkedIn profile to evaluate their expertise. Have they been job-hopping between agencies, or do they have a stable track record of delivering results? A strong technical SEO should have a reputation for sticking around and showing consistent success in their roles.
2. Avoid Getting Blindsided by Agency Awards or Big-Name Clients
While it’s tempting to be impressed by an agency’s awards or recognisable logos on their client list, these can be misleading when it comes to technical SEO. Remember: an agency is only as good as the people working on your website. You may find that the person handling your account is not the person who drove those big results for the other high-profile clients.
Instead, focus on the individual technical SEO expert. Ask the agency specifically about who will be assigned to your project, and request to see their portfolio. What specific improvements have they made in past projects? Have they worked with businesses that have similar challenges to yours? Always ask for case studies that showcase the work of the actual person who will be managing your technical SEO needs.
3. Assess Their Expertise in Handling Large Websites
A seasoned technical SEO professional should be able to easily demonstrate specific improvements they have made to large, enterprise-level websites. Ask about technical audits they’ve conducted and the solutions they implemented. Have they worked with complex CMS platforms like your, whether that be WordPress VIP, Magento, Magnolia, Demandware, or custom-built headless solutions?
Key technical areas they should excel in include:
- Optimising site architecture for better crawling and indexing.
- Addressing canonicalisation and duplicate content issues.
- Streamlining page load speeds and optimising for Core Web Vitals.
- Setting up effective schema markup for rich results.
- Handling different types of migrations including; HTTP to HTTPS, Replatform migrations, domain name migrations, site mergers etc.
- Exceptional data analysis abilities: Data insights from analytics platforms will be the north star for a good technical SEO expert
Look for concrete, measurable outcomes—like improved traffic, conversions and revenue.
4. Evaluate Their Problem-Solving and Innovation Skills
Technical SEO often requires creative problem-solving. Every website, especially large ones, comes with its own set of unique challenges. The SEO expert handling your account should be resourceful in diagnosing issues and proactive in offering cutting-edge solutions. Have they innovated with emerging technologies like headless CMS or Progressive Web Apps (PWA)? Can they demonstrate thought leadership in technical SEO—perhaps through blog posts, speaking engagements, or industry forums?
Don’t just ask about their successes—ask how they approached problems they didn’t foresee and how they adapted.
5. Examine Their Long-Term Commitment
Technical SEO is not a “set it and forget it” job. It requires long-term strategy, maintenance, and ongoing optimisations, because as long as you have developers making changes, you’ll have new SEO issued cropping up.
When selecting an agency, you need to ensure the technical SEO expert assigned to you will stay long enough to make an impact. A common issue in SEO agencies is high staff turnover. You don’t want to end up with a revolving door of SEO consultants.
Look into the expert’s history: do they have a reputation for sticking with clients or agencies long-term? Job-hopping could indicate a lack of commitment, which can be risky for businesses with ongoing, large-scale SEO needs.
6. Request Hands-On Demonstrations or Audits
One of the best ways to assess an agency’s technical SEO expertise is to request a mini-audit or a demonstration of their processes. This could be a crawl analysis, a review of your site’s indexing, or a preliminary check of your Core Web Vitals. A capable technical SEO should be able to identify and explain potential issues with your site on the spot, outlining how they would approach fixing them.
This hands-on approach will help you gauge their knowledge, communication skills, and ability to collaborate with your in-house team. Plus, it gives you a preview of what working with them will be like.
Technical SEO Success Starts with the Right Expert
Choosing the right technical SEO agency boils down to choosing the right individual expert. Look beyond the accolades and big-name clients, and focus on who will be working on your website. Investigate their track record, request to see their specific past work, and ensure they have deep technical expertise relevant to your site’s needs.
At Spark SEO, we offer direct access to Fion McCormack, a seasoned SEO expert with 15 years of technical SEO experience. Fion has worked with major brands, national and international – like eBay, Sephora, Gumtree, Tesco, Mothercare, Osprey, and Vodafone, delivering impactful results across large, complex websites. If you’re looking for someone who can handle the unique challenges of any large-scale site, Fion’s expertise will ensure your technical SEO is in the best hands. Reach out to explore how we can elevate your website’s performance and visibility through technical SEO